No Matter How Good You Think Harrison Smith Is, He’s Better Than You Think He Is

Harrison Smith

Very few serious NFL fans need to be reminded that Harrison Smith is underrated—although he was a pro bowl snub, by this point, even most casual fans probably know that Harrison Smith is one of the best safeties in football.

But it is hard to overstate just how underrated Harrison Smith is. He’s not just one of the better safeties in football right now — he is the best. Full stop. He’s not just an elite safety; he’s arguably the best player in football right now.

Sounds absolutely absurd, right? Well, consider the following:

Harrison Smith was the highest-graded player in football in 2017.

Harrison Smith outgraded Aaron Donald, Bobby Wagner, Tom Brady, Antonio Brown, Rob Gronkowski, Von Miller, and every other player in the league this year.

What’s more, Harrison Smith ended the 2017 season as the highest-graded safety in Pro Football Focus’s history. And even that understates it — Harrison Smith ended the 2017 season with a final PFF grade of 98.8. The next best season by a safety ever is Eric Weddle’s 2012, which graded out to 93.4. The very best seasons from Ed Reed, Troy Polamalu, Earl Thomas, Eric Weddle or Landon Collins don’t even come close to how Harrison Smith’s season graded out.

But maybe you don’t put much stock into PFF grades. Fair enough — then consider this next point:

Harrison Smith had a passer rating allowed of just 22.0 this season, the lowest mark from any safety OR cornerback in 2017.

Just to be clear, that’s not normal. Earl Thomas, arguably the best coverage safety in the NFL, had a passer rating allowed of 80.9 this season. Smith was four-times better than that. Throwing the ball into the dirt on every snap would grant a quarterback a passer rating of 39.6. And yet that would still be nearly twice as good as throwing the ball at Harrison Smith. Last season, Xavier Rhodes had the best passer rating allowed of any cornerback in the NFL, with a passer rating allowed of 47.0. Harrison Smith’s 2017 passer rating allowed is less than half of that. A.J. Bouye just completed a historic season where he surrendered a passer rating allowed of just 31.6, the lowest figure among cornerbacks. Harrison Smith beat that figure by nearly ten points.

Smith didn’t give up a touchdown in coverage all season, and he had five interceptions and 17 pass deflections. Smith was targeted 42 times on the season, giving up just 23 receptions for 140 yards. For comparison, Earl Thomas gave up more yards (160) on less than half the amount of targets. Smith’s 0.25 yards allowed per coverage snap is among the lowest of any player at any position in the NFL, and his passer rating allowed is absolutely unprecedented.

But Harrison Smith is so much more than an elite coverage safety:

Harrison Smith is one of the best run-stuffing defensive backs in football AND is the most productive pass-rushing defensive back in football

Harrison Smith had 17 run stops this season, and had a run stop percentage of 7.4% when playing in the box–good for top ten among all safeties. Smith sets the edge in run defense like he’s Khalil Mack:

He makes every tackle. Smith had just two missed tackles in the run game all year–more than three times less than other elite run defending safeties like Reshad Jones, Landon Collins or Keanu Neal.

As a pass rusher, Harrison Smith is one of six defensive backs in the entire NFL to have a total number of sacks, hits and hurries in the double digits. He blitzes with an insane level of burst and bend for a defensive back:

No defensive back was as productive on as few snaps as Smith. Tyrann Mathieu, one of the best pass-rushing defensive backs in football, had one sack, one hit, and ten hurries on the season over 55 pass rushing snaps. Harrison Smith was more effective as a pass rusher, with two sacks, one hit, and seven hurries on the season on literally half as many pass rushing snaps.

Which underscores just how versatile Harrison Smith is:

Harrison Smith is arguably the most versatile defender in the football

Here is a chart covering just how many positions Harrison Smith plays on defense:

Smith plays about a third of his snaps (35%) as an off-ball linebacker. He plays about a quarter of his snaps (24%) as a slot cornerback. 18% of his snaps come as a free safety, and 16% of his snaps come as an edge rusher, typically lined up in a 7-technique or wide-9 (like a 3-4 OLB). His remaining snaps come as an outside cornerback and as a strong safety.

Smith plays a lot of man coverage, especially for a safety. And he’s equally as good in zone as he is in man.

Man or zone, Cover-1 or Cover-6, edge rusher or outside cornerback, Harrison Smith can truly do it all. And he’s the only player that does it all at an elite level. He’s a more productive pass rusher than Tyrann Mathieu, a better coverage defender than Earl Thomas, and a better run defender than Landon Collins.

Harrison Smith’s versatility allows him to be arguably the best pre-snap defensive player in football.

Mike Zimmer recently said that when he first arrived in Minnesota, Harrison Smith knew how to play safety. But now he knows every position on the defense–not just because he plays them, but because he tells everyone else how to play them as well.

Here’s an example:

As soon as Smith sees the man in motion in this play, Smith runs over to the slot cornerback, Mackenzie Alexander, to let him know that (based on the revised pass protection and pass rush) he’ll have a free lane to the QB and that he should blitz. Smith hops back into coverage on the other side of the field, and Alexander gets immediate pressure on the QB. This goes down on the stat sheet as a pressure from Alexander, but it’s Harrison Smith that made it happen.

On this play,

Harrison Smith knows where the ball is going based on the pre-snap look. He knows there’s a crossing route, so he lurks in coverage underneath until Hundley targets Nelson. Smith makes a diving, one-handed interception, all because he knew where the ball was going before even the offense did.

Harrison Smith read this next play immediately:

As soon as the man is put in motion, Smith recognizes the look and comes crashing down pre-snap, eluding a blocker and making the stop.

So not only is Smith the Vikings’ pre-snap field general, he’s also a quarterback mind reader. Good quarterbacks know not to throw the ball at a shutdown cornerback or ballhawking safety. The only problem is that with Smith, they can never tell where he’s going to be.

They’d avoid him if they could, but they can’t.

That leads me to my last point:

Harrison Smith is irreplaceable.

Von Miller, Aaron Donald, Jalen Ramsey and Luke Kuechly are all absolutely elite players. If one of them goes down, their team is significantly worse off. And yet, there are backups who can still play their position if they go down.

There is no backup who can play Harrison Smith’s position.

No one else can play man coverage in the slot, blitz off the edge and play single-high coverage, each on the same playcall depending on the pre-snap look.

Harrison Smith missed two games for the Vikings last year. Before he went down, they were averaging 17.4 points allowed per game–second best in the NFL. When Smith went down, that shot up to 25 points per game–good for 8th worst in the NFL on the season.

Harrison Smith played all 16 games this season, and directly as a result, the 2017 Minnesota Vikings lead the league in points allowed and yards allowed, and they have the best third down defense in NFL history. None of that is remotely possible without Harrison Smith.

Harrison Smith might just be the best player in football. He’s the highest-graded player in football. His passer rating allowed this year of 22.0 is historically low. He is the best run defender among all defensive backs. And he is the best pass rusher among defensive backs. He’s not just an elite safety — he’s an elite cornerback, an elite linebacker, and maybe even an elite edge defender.

No matter how good you think Harrison Smith is, he’s better than you think he is.


For more on Harrison Smith and the Vikings, follow me on Twitter here.